Silly question, who should win in a melee?

[ds4502]

Malekith or Nagash? I have not really had the time to look over Nagash's rules yet, just curious if you think that the mage-killer lord, stands a chance against Nagash.

[Black Templar]

There is an entire thread on Warseer about characters fighting Nagash - not much can take him down alone.

[Ninja Goblin]

To be fair only Sigmar and a crazed tomb king with the Fellblade were successful (well mostly) in the old fluff so makes sense..

[SkavenInAZ]

Tomb king with the Fellblade? Try Skaven assassin.

[Ninja Goblin]

Try reading the fluff in the book! Alcardaz (spelling) the mad was given that blade by the 13 to kill the Great Necomancer. After his attempt (and going insane) the Fell blade was retaken by the skaven

Ninja Vanish

[SkavenInAZ]

Right. We gave him the blade, which makes him a Skaven assassin. I rest my case.

[Ninja Goblin]

He is neither skaven (a ratman chaos beast) nor an actual assassin (a murderer of an important person in a surprise attack for political or religious reasons), as he failed to actually kill Nagash.

But as you did rest your case I will have to assume I have won this debate!